Crisis point: why doing what you've always done won't keep your dealership open
The dealer association says Australian dealers have hit a crisis point. Here's what has changed, and where the profit you can still control is hiding.
This month the Australian Automotive Dealer Association (AADA) confirmed that dealers recorded a loss for the September quarter. It is the first negative quarter for dealer profitability since the global financial crisis.
AADA CEO James Voortman called it "a clear warning that the commercial settings underpinning our industry are becoming unsustainable" (carsales).
If you have spent 20 or 30 years in this industry, you have seen hard years before. This one is different. The pressure is coming from several directions at once, and most of it is outside your control.
What has changed
The market has filled up faster than the business model can absorb. According to the AADA and October VFACTS figures:
More brands chasing the same buyers. Australia now has 67 car brands, up from 39 in 2021.
A fast shift to Chinese-built cars. They took 36.3% of new car sales in October and 31.3% for the year to date. October sales of China-built vehicles were up 94% on last year.
More stock pushed onto dealers. Factories are pushing more stock onto dealers while costs rise and margins shrink. Voortman says this is fuelling a race to the bottom.
More risk on the service side. The AADA warns that too many brands means faster depreciation, slower parts supply, longer repair times, and orphaned owners when a brand leaves.
The AADA has asked Canberra to pause new brands, freeze supplier price rises for 12 months, and make manufacturers help with excess stock. Whether the Government acts is uncertain.
Voortman's warning is worth repeating in plain terms: a dealership can post strong sales and still be in serious financial trouble.
Why doing what you've always done won't work
For decades, the new-car margin carried the business. With 67 brands fighting for the same buyers, that margin is not coming back any time soon.
You can't control how many brands arrive, how much stock the factory sends, or what Canberra decides. Waiting for someone else to fix it is not a plan.
What you can control is your service department. Every car sold in the last five years, whatever the badge, needs servicing. And with parts slower and repairs taking longer, customers have less patience. The dealer who makes service easy will keep them.
Dealers overseas have already made this shift. In The Presidio Group's year-end survey of US dealers, 85% named parts and service as the main driver of their business in 2026 (Digital Dealer).
Yet many service departments still run the way they did 20 years ago:
Customers queue at 7:30am to hand over keys.
Advisors spend the day on the phone chasing approvals.
Extra work is explained over the phone, and the customer says "I'll leave it for now".
Keys can only be dropped off or collected while the service desk is open.
Each of these costs you money every day. In a good year you could carry them. This year you can't.
Where the profit is: the repair order
Service revenue comes down to two numbers: how many cars come through, and how much each repair order (RO) is worth. Lifting the second can matter as much as finding more cars.
A simple example: 75 cars at $400 an RO brings in $30,000. That beats 100 cars at $250, which brings in $25,000. Fewer cars, more revenue.
So how do you lift the RO without hard selling? Research from North America (Kimoby) points the same way:
Customers want to see the problem. 64% of service customers want a photo or video with their inspection, but only 26% of mass-market customers get one (J.D. Power, 2026).
Digital conversations lift the RO. Across 16.8 million ROs at 871 stores, ROs with a digital conversation averaged about US$164 more in customer-pay work.
Text is faster than the phone. Quotes sent by text had a median approval time of 6 minutes. Phone approvals took 22 to 23 hours.
These figures come from a supplier's own report and show links, not proof, so treat them as direction rather than a promise. But the direction is clear. Make it easy for customers to see the work and say yes, and more of them will.
Three changes to make now
None of these need extra staff or a new building. They change how the service drive runs.
Take the queue out of the morning. Let customers check in from home on their phone and drop their keys in a secure locker, from 6am to 6pm. They can be offered extras like wiper blades or a wheel alignment before they arrive, when they have time to think about it. Your advisors start the day on the cars, not the queue.
Show the customer, don't just tell them. The technician films the worn brake pads or the leaking hose. The advisor adds the quote, and the customer watches it on their phone. A customer who can see the problem is far more likely to approve the fix.
Get approvals and payment by text. Send the quote and a payment link by SMS. The customer taps to approve and pays before they arrive, so the car leaves the moment it is ready and your advisors stop chasing callbacks.
Each change removes a delay that costs you work today. Together, they let the same team handle more cars and earn more from each one.
What it costs: less than you might think
In a tight year, every new cost gets questioned, and it should. The good news is that key drop-off can pay for itself.
Here is a worked example for a dealership writing 1,000 ROs a month. We assume half of customers check in from home once it is established (about a quarter in the first few months). We also assume 1 in 10 of them adds an extra item worth about $100.
Net gain after all costs: $9,663 in Year 1, then $17,412 a year
Cost per key transaction: $2.65 in Year 1, then $1.90
Add-on rate needed to break even: 1 in 18 (Year 1)
Advisor time freed up: 42 hours a month
Year 1 includes the locker and the slower start. If only 1 in 18 home check-ins adds an item, the locker and software are covered. Anything above that is profit, plus shorter queues and happier advisors at no net cost.
This is a worked example, not a guarantee. Use the ROI calculator to run the numbers for your own rooftop.
The dealers who adapt will be the ones still here
The AADA is right to push for change in Canberra. But no policy will bring back the old margins on new cars, and no dealer can afford to wait and see.
The dealerships that come through this will be the ones that run their service department like the profit centre it now is. That means no queues, customers who can see the work, and approvals in minutes rather than days.




Comments